Mate's Table
Subscribe
Create
Share with the community

What would you like to make?

Add a recommendationShare a place worth gathering around.Create a guideBuild a useful list for your city.
For business

Restaurant

458 Pizzeria

458 Neerim Rd, Murrumbeena VIC 3163, Australia

Recommended by 39 people

Updated

Find 458 Pizzeria

458 Neerim Rd, Murrumbeena VIC 3163, Australia

Directions ↗
+61 3 9563 1432
HoursMonday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM Tuesday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM Wednesday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM Thursday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM Friday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM Saturday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM Sunday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM

*Opening hours may differ during holidays.

Book Now

About 458 Pizzeria

Murrumbeena’s neighborhood fixture turns out European-style stone-oven pizzas marked by blistered crusts and fresh toppings. Fast takeaway without the grease—the thin base stays crisp all the way home. Regulars point newcomers toward the Giacomo, the Pollo, or the Quattro Formaggi, with the open kitchen rolling, topping, and baking every pie in clear view. For parties, dozens of boxes fly out the door without a dip in standards. Dinner finishes on a sweet note with house tiramisu.

  • Light, blistered crust: Stone-baked European dough yields a light, bubbly crust that holds its crispness on the drive home.
  • Party catering made easy: Reliable catering handles 15 to 17 varied pizzas for parties without sacrificing bake quality or speed.
  • Open kitchen counter: Guests can watch the counter team toss, top, and fire pizzas in an open, spotless prep space.
RestaurantItalianRestaurant

What's On at 458 Pizzeria

Upcoming events, special menus and other reasons to plan a visit.

No events or specials listed right now.

Why Choose 458 Pizzeria

Why local diners and party hosts rely on 458 Pizzeria for authentic taste and genuine hospitality.

  • Light, Crispy-Soft Stone Oven Crust

    Dough is prepared in authentic European style, baking up light and airy with a balanced crispness that never feels heavy or oily.

    The pizza was fresh, with a crispy yet soft crust and well-balanced toppings.

    Himanshi Balsara

  • Fresh Takeaway That Stays Hot

    Pizzas are prepared efficiently with quality fresh ingredients, retaining their heat and crust integrity during travel.

    Great base, not heavy or greasy, fresh ingredients, ordered on my way and was ready upon arrival, stayed nice and warm after a 10 min drive home.

    yon python

  • Hassle-Free Bulk Catering

    Large event orders across multiple varieties are handled seamlessly, keeping groups satisfied without greasy heaviness.

    Super yummy, not oily, we ordered 15 pizzas 7 or so different types and they were all super yummy!

    lauren Hart

  • Celebration-Ready Party Orders

    Bulk celebration orders are coordinated smoothly, delivering consistent quality that delights all attendees.

    Ordered 17 pizzas last night for my wife’s birthday party. And everyone of our guests absolutely loved the pizzas.

    Robert Hart

  • Heartfelt Support in Mishaps

    Staff step in with genuine kindness and complimentary remakes when dinner mishaps occur during exhausting evenings.

    They made me another and refused payment. How sweet is that. I will NEVER eat pizza anywhere else.

    Sandi Power

  • Reassuring Care for Families

    Dependable customer service resolves third-party ordering setbacks immediately to protect family dinner routines.

    A big thank you to all the staff who gave us a free dinner after a food delivery service lost our order.

    Jason Matser

Authentic stone-baked favourites crafted on thin, crispy European dough

  • The 458 Pizza

    My Pick is The 458 Pizza

    Natalie Burcul

  • Margherita

    I really liked the Margherita, it is the best in the area!

    Natassa Nancy

  • Giacomo pizza

    Giacomo pizza is a fave.

    Camilla Ryzner

  • Pollo

    The flavours of the Pollo were on point.

    Mitch Crawford

Beyond the menu

Thoughtful gestures and service moments that make local takeaway feel cared for

  • No-Fault Replacement Dinners

    When mishaps happen—whether an order is dropped on the street or lost in transit—staff make and hand over a fresh replacement dinner free of charge.

  • Open-View Kitchen Craft

    The counter layout lets guests watch the dough tossing and stone-oven baking in action while waiting for their takeaway.

  • Seamless Event Catering Coordination

    Large orders of 15 to 17 varied stone-baked pizzas are smoothly scheduled, timed, and boxed fresh for birthdays and gatherings without sacrificing crispness.

  • Thoughtful Dietary Accommodations

    Dedicated gluten-free pizza crust options are prepared alongside traditional dough so dietary-conscious diners and families can share focaccias and pizzas comfortably.

Frequently Asked Questions

How should I order takeaway?

You can order directly in-store or online for pickup and delivery. Note that ordering in the shop is often cheaper than third-party platforms like DoorDash, and phone or advance pickup orders travel well.

What pizzas and menu items are most recommended?

Customer favourites include the signature 458 Pizza, Margherita, Giacomo, Pollo, Quattro Formaggi with blue cheese, and Garlic & Cheese focaccia. Pairings like homemade tiramisu are also popular.

Can 458 Pizzeria accommodate large group or party orders?

Yes, 458 Pizzeria handles large catering orders smoothly, successfully preparing party orders of 15 to 17 pizzas across diverse varieties with advance notice.

Are vegetarian and gluten-free options available?

Yes, vegetarian pizzas are available on the menu, and gluten-free crust bases are also offered.

Explore more places in Melbourne

Find familiar flavours, neighbourhood favourites and somewhere new in Melbourne.

More in Murrumbeena

Keep exploring this neighbourhood.

Browse all Melbourne venues