Restaurant
Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Flinders Lane
289 Flinders Ln, Melbourne VIC 3000, Australia
Find Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Flinders Lane
289 Flinders Ln, Melbourne VIC 3000, Australia
Directions ↗*Opening hours may differ during holidays.
Book NowAbout Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Flinders Lane
Piping-hot New York slices hit the counter fast on Flinders Lane, dishing out proper foldable crusts without forcing you into a whole pie. Slices get finished back in the deck oven until crisp and molten—ideal for a quick city transit bite or a solo pit stop. Longtime regulars lean into classic pepperoni, spicy buffalo chicken, and sides of cool ranch, while groups tackle massive shareable pies loaded with house-made plant-based cheese or charred sausage.
- Counter-Service Slices: Oversized single slices re-crisped to order in the pizza oven, alongside shareable multi-person whole pies.
- House-Made Vegan Cheese: Proprietary house-made Sal Notzarella available on specialty plant-based pies like the Staten Island.
What's On at Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Flinders Lane
Upcoming events, special menus and other reasons to plan a visit.
No events or specials listed right now.
Why Diners Choose Sal's Authentic New York Pizza
Grab authentic New York-style slices finished crisp to order in the heart of Melbourne.
Oversized Slices by the Cut
Counter service lets guests order individual oversized slices reheated crisp to order in the deck oven rather than having to commit to a whole pie.
the best thing I like is that we can only order per slice instead of a whole
Cindy C Rahardjo Oven-Finished Piping-Hot Delivery
Pre-baked slices are returned to the deck oven upon ordering, ensuring a piping-hot finish with a balanced chew and crisp crust.
Beyond what I was expecting for a single slice that is finished back off in the pizza oven and came out so hot.
TK Studio Authentic Street-Corner Energy
The lively counter service, music, and authentic slice style transport guests straight into a bustling NYC or Brooklyn street pizzeria.
I really felt like I was on the streets of Brooklyn gabbing a slice from a little shop.
Finn Van Den Bogaert Reassuring Portion Value
Generous slice dimensions and massive full-size pies ensure customers leave thoroughly satisfied with strong portion value.
I really could not care less about paying a bit more per slice because it was worth every cent to me.
ilikeitlikekat Classic American Slice-Shop Fixings
Authentic New York details—from floppy, foldable thin crusts to house sides of ranch dressing—satisfy specific cravings uncommon in Melbourne.
They even have sides of ranch dressing which has also been quite difficult to find at other pizza places in aus!
Taia Hara Proprietary Vegan Notzarella
Dedicated vegan options feature Sal Notzarella, a proprietary house-made plant-based cheese crafted for authentic melting and taste.
The vegan pizza is a must-try! It’s made with their own house-made cheese (perfect if you don’t have a nut allergy) and tastes fantastic.
Yilmaz A
Most popular items
Authentic New York-style slices and whole pies finished piping hot from the oven
Pepperoni Pizza
The pepperoni slice? Crispy, cheesy and delicious.
Apoorva Rai Buffalo Chicken Pizza
The buffalo chicken? Spicy, saucy and absolutely unhinged in the best way.
Apoorva Rai Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage and pepperoni pizza was delicious. Beyond what I was expecting for a single slice that is finished back off in the pizza oven and came out so hot.
TK Studio 5 Boroughs Pizza
I got a slice of the pepperoni and a slice of the 5 boroughs (mozzarella, creamy ricotta, black garlic sauce, marinara, pesto). Perfect amount of crisp to the crust and perfect amount of cheese.
Taia Hara
Before you head over
Practical advice on counter ordering, seating limits, and dietary options before you go
Plan Ahead for Limited Seating
Seating inside is tight and fills quickly, especially for parties over five people. Opt for a quick counter stop or take your slices to go if you are with a larger group.
Ask What Just Came Out of the Oven
Counter slices are finished back off in the oven so they arrive piping hot. Ask staff what is just coming out fresh for the best crunch and temperature.
Check House Vegan Cheese for Nut Allergies
Plant-based eaters can order pizzas made with custom house-made Sal Notzarella, but take note that the house recipe uses nuts if anyone has an allergy.
Explore more places in Melbourne
Find familiar flavours, neighbourhood favourites and somewhere new in Melbourne.
Similar places
More places for the flavours and food you enjoy.
- Pizza E VinoNorthcote · Pizza, Italian, Restaurant, Takeaway
- Cargo Bar & EateryDocklands · Pizza, Mexican, Restaurant, Bar, Cocktail Bar
- Mumma Gs Pizza & PastaPakenham · Pizza, Italian, Takeaway, Restaurant
- FRESH DOUGH PIZZA AND KEBAB SAINT ALBANSSaint Albans · Pizza, Restaurant
- Il Birrificio PizzeriaCamberwell · Italian, Pizza, Restaurant
- La Q Woodfire Pizza & Italian Restaurant (BYO)Kew · Italian, Pizza, Restaurant, Takeaway
Discover more in Melbourne
Explore another side of the city's food and drink.
- Wee Jeanie cafeYarraville · Coffee, Cafe, Restaurant
- Ferntree Thai RestaurantFerntree Gully · Thai, Restaurant, Takeaway
- The D's SouvlakiAirport West · Fast Food, Restaurant
- Korner & Co.Bentleigh East · Coffee, Cafe
- Flower Drum Restaurant MelbourneMelbourne · Chinese, Cantonese, Restaurant
- AbeshaFootscray · Ethiopian, Restaurant
- Hamilton's Coffee • Burgers • Fried ChickenMont Albert · Coffee, Brunch, Burger, Cafe, Restaurant
- Kung Fu SushiOrmond · Japanese, Restaurant, Takeaway
- nature cafe barFrankston · Vegetarian, Coffee, Restaurant, Cafe
- Hunky Dory Fish & Chips BentleighBentleigh · Seafood, Fish & Chips, Restaurant
- Nonna Rosa Cafe and RestaurantGlenroy · Italian, Restaurant
- Fourth ChapterPrahran · Coffee, Brunch, Cafe, Restaurant
