Mate's Table
Subscribe
Create
Share with the community

What would you like to make?

Add a recommendationShare a place worth gathering around.Create a guideBuild a useful list for your city.
For business

Restaurant

Casa Mia

342 Bay Rd, Cheltenham VIC 3192, Australia

Recommended by 60 people

Updated

Find Casa Mia

342 Bay Rd, Cheltenham VIC 3192, Australia

Directions ↗
+61 3 9585 3333
HoursMonday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Tuesday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Wednesday: Closed Thursday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Friday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM Saturday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM Sunday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM

*Opening hours may differ during holidays.

Book Now

About Casa Mia

Cheltenham locals treat this neighborhood kitchen as a reliable standby for quick-fire comfort food, turning out crisp-bottomed pies, chicken parmas, and saucy risottos. The broad menu balances reliable family staples with unexpected specialty creations—think Sichuan-style slices and Moroccan lamb—while the oven runs late into the night until midnight.

  • Open Late Until 12 AM: Oven-baked classics and late-night cravings covered until midnight on Bay Road.
  • Beyond Pizza: From crisp schnitzels and parmas to hearty pasta, burgers, and gourmet risottos.
  • Cross-Cuisine Signatures: Creative signatures include spicy Sichuan-style slices alongside Avocado Prawn and Moroccan Lamb.
RestaurantPizzaBurgerRestaurantTakeaway

What's On at Casa Mia

Upcoming events, special menus and other reasons to plan a visit.

No events or specials listed right now.

Why Choose Casa Mia

Why Cheltenham locals rely on Casa Mia for family dinners, gatherings, and late-night cravings

  • One Order Covers Every Appetite

    With a kitchen that prepares pizzas, pastas, risottos, burgers, and schnitzels, households can satisfy diverse cravings in a single order.

    Ordered the Meat Deluxe and Vegetatian Supreme which covers both ends of the pizza spectrum, along with a chicken gourmet risotto.

    Matthew Shepherd

  • Effortless Family Dinners Delivered On Time

    Reliable meal prep and convenient online takeout make busy weekday dinners simple, satisfying kids and parents alike.

    My kids loved the burgers and chips and I thought the primavera vegetarian risotto was delicious.

    Rochelle Gaudin

  • Crowd-Pleasing Food for Group Gatherings

    Whether hosting friends or organizing party catering, sharing familiar crowd-pleasers ensures everyone leaves full and happy.

    Also I had friends over they also enjoyed the pizzas and asked where I got it from

    irmak Altinkalp

  • The Dependable Friday Night Tradition

    Dependable sizing and crowd-tested favorites take the stress out of feeding larger groups and lively Friday family nights.

    Kids keep asking me for Casa Mia on Friday nights. It's now our go-to place. And they've done well in the past on several occasions when we need to do a big order for a party.

    Paul Cockerall

  • Hot Meals Available Late Into the Night

    Operating through the evening until midnight, Casa Mia provides hot, freshly prepared meals when most local kitchens have closed.

    Great Pizza that's avaible at night, definitely one of my top options for pizza in Cheltenham (and open till 12 AM too!)

    Alex Gondopoulos

  • Inventive Specialties Alongside Classic Favorites

    Specialty chef creations like Sichuan-style Chinese pizza, Avocado Prawn, and Moroccan Lamb offer exciting options beyond classic takeout.

    Avocado Prawn, Peri Chicken and Morroccan Lamb are the top 3 in my opinion.

    Sethrith SEAN

Signature specialty pizzas and hearty comfort mains favored by local households

  • Avocado Prawn Pizza

    Avocado Prawn, Peri Chicken and Morroccan Lamb are the top 3 in my opinion.

    Sethrith SEAN

  • Moroccan Lamb Pizza

    Avocado Prawn, Peri Chicken and Morroccan Lamb are the top 3 in my opinion.

    Sethrith SEAN

  • Chicken Schnitzel

    We are also fans of the chicken schnitzel, it has a yummy crumb and the pizzas in general.

    Jenny Bennett

  • Primavera Vegetarian Risotto

    I thought the primavera vegetarian risotto was delicious.

    Rochelle Gaudin

Beyond the menu

Thoughtful touches and attentive hospitality that make Casa Mia a neighborhood staple.

  • Personal Hospitality from Owner-Chef Jack

    Owner and chef Jack personally looks after regulars, chatting with diners and checking in on custom orders.

  • Dietary Accommodations & Custom Requests

    The kitchen happily accommodates individual dietary needs and custom preparation requests so everyone in the family gets exactly what they need.

  • Careful Handling of Large Group & Party Orders

    Orders are freshly prepared and packaged reliably for big group gatherings and Friday night family orders.

  • Late-Night Midnight Service Care

    Late-night diners can pick up freshly cooked hot pizzas and meals up until midnight.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Casa Mia serve dishes other than pizza?

Beyond traditional pizzas, the kitchen prepares pastas such as pesto chicken tortellini, risottos (including chicken gourmet and vegetarian primavera), chicken schnitzel, parmigianas, and burgers.

Can dietary requirements and special requests be accommodated?

Yes. Reviewers note that staff gladly accommodate dietary needs and special requests, with vegetarian choices available like the vegetarian supreme pizza and primavera risotto.

Are delivery and takeaway available?

Yes. Casa Mia offers both online and phone ordering with options for takeaway pickup as well as fast home delivery.

Can you dine in at Casa Mia?

Yes. While popular for takeout, the restaurant offers dine-in seating, including a window-side table.

Explore more places in Melbourne

Find familiar flavours, neighbourhood favourites and somewhere new in Melbourne.

Browse all Melbourne venues