Mate's Table
Subscribe
Create
Share with the community

What would you like to make?

Add a recommendationShare a place worth gathering around.Create a guideBuild a useful list for your city.
For business

Restaurant

Pizza This Pizza That

84 Baxter-Tooradin Rd, Baxter VIC 3911, Australia

Recommended by 50 people

Updated

Find Pizza This Pizza That

84 Baxter-Tooradin Rd, Baxter VIC 3911, Australia

Directions ↗
+61 3 5971 3821
HoursMonday: 4:00 – 9:00 PM Tuesday: 4:00 – 9:00 PM Wednesday: 4:00 – 9:00 PM Thursday: 4:00 – 9:00 PM Friday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Saturday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Sunday: 4:00 – 9:00 PM

*Opening hours may differ during holidays.

Book Now

About Pizza This Pizza That

Old-school crusts with crisp undercarriages and generous toppings define this no-nonsense Baxter pizza stop. Dough avoids factory-made shortcuts, baking up light with toasted cheese along the rim. Regulars rely on the Aussie, while hearty orders lean toward the Souvlaki pizza packed with spiced lamb. Orders move straight to the door via dedicated in-house drivers, accompanied by hot chips and chocolate mousse.

  • Scratch-Baked Crusts: Dough skips premade bulk bases for thin crusts with a crisp undercarriage and toasted cheese edges.
  • Souvlaki Pizza: Topped with generous portions of spiced lamb, alongside classics like the Aussie and Spicey Special.
  • Dedicated Delivery: Deliveries run via in-house staff who bring swap options right to the door if a drink flavor runs out.
RestaurantPizzaRestaurant

What's On at Pizza This Pizza That

Upcoming events, special menus and other reasons to plan a visit.

No events or specials listed right now.

Why Choose Pizza This Pizza That

Why Baxter locals rely on Pizza This Pizza That for their takeaway and delivery nights

  • Dedicated In-House Delivery

    Deliveries are managed directly by the venue rather than impersonal third-party apps, ensuring timely arrivals and attentive service.

    When I have ordered delivery they have always been punctual.

    Elle Jade

  • Traditional Handcrafted Bases

    Dough is prepared in-house rather than using pre-formed commercial bulk disks, delivering a classic crust with balanced toppings.

    Awesome old school pizza none of that bulk ordered bases and a genorous spread of toppings

    David Rickard

  • Customized Toppings and Builds

    The kitchen accommodates tailored requests, split halves, and heavy extra toppings without rigid menu restrictions.

    it will cost a little extra, and you will get the greatest pepperoni pizza experience of your life.

    Tony Huddy

  • Craving-Satisfying Extended Menu

    Beyond classic pizzas, the kitchen serves hot, freshly prepared favorites like homemade lasagna, risotto, and crispy seasoned wedges.

    Potato wedges and lasagne are to die for.

    Tanvi Vira

  • Rediscovered Local Pizza Quality

    Customers enjoy the relief of finding a consistent local favourite that delivers piping hot meals every time.

    Beautiful fresh and piping hot pizzas with generous but not too many toppings.

    Jason

  • Thoughtful Neighborhood Hospitality

    Guests feel appreciated through attentive service, consistent high standards, and thoughtful extras that make orders special.

    Every time I order, the pizzas are always fresh, flavorful, and made with top-quality ingredients.

    Amy Téa

Locally loved pizzas and traditional comfort mains baked fresh

  • Lasagne

    Potato wedges and lasagne are to die for.

    Tanvi Vira

  • Pepperoni Pizza

    My personal favorite is the pepperoni pizza

    Hardik Patel

  • Souvlaki Pizza

    It was very tasty, and I was most impressed with the really generous amount of lamb.

    John Kitchen

  • Spicey Special Pizza

    Tonight I tried the Spicey Special pizza and it was the perfect amount of heat, couldn't fault it at all.

    Jason

Other favorites

Complement your pizza with house-made sides, fresh salads, and desserts

  • Garlic Bread

    come to pick up pizzas or even just the amazing garlic bread at least a few times a week!

    Hayley Swanson

  • Potato Wedges

    Potato wedges and lasagne are to die for.

    Tanvi Vira

  • Chocolate Mousse

    chocolate mousse

    Jason

  • Caesar Salad

    she says it's the best Caesaer when compared to other pizza restaurants in the area.

    Jason

Beyond the menu

Thoughtful touches and attentive gestures that elevate Baxter's local pizza experience.

  • Doorstep Drink Selection for Substitutions

    When ordered items like specific sodas are unavailable, in-house delivery drivers bring a bag of alternative drink choices right to the door so customers can select a substitute in person.

  • Personalized Celebration Extras and Delivery Wishes

    When celebration notes are left on remote orders, the team includes complimentary garlic bread and treats, alongside in-person birthday greetings at delivery.

  • Surprise Treats and Desserts for Families

    Regular customers and families frequently find unexpected perks packed with their orders, ranging from surprise drinks and garlic bread to free chocolate mousse for the kids.

  • Accommodating Custom Build Requests

    Special orders—from half-meat splits to specific heavy customizations like extra pepperoni—are accommodated attentively by the kitchen staff.

Before you head over

Practical guidance to help you order seamlessly and enjoy the best takeaway experience

  • Customize Your Order and Toppings

    If you have specific ingredient preferences or want half-and-half toppings, clearly communicate your custom requests or extra toppings when ordering, as the kitchen accommodates specific modifications.

  • Expect In-House Driver Delivery

    When ordering delivery via third-party apps, note that the restaurant delivers their own food with their in-house drivers rather than gig app couriers, offering direct service right to your door.

  • Explore Extended Menu Specialties

    Take a moment while ordering to explore extended menu options like souvlaki pizza, wedges, lasagna, and risotto, which pair well alongside traditional pizza styles.

Explore more places in Melbourne

Find familiar flavours, neighbourhood favourites and somewhere new in Melbourne.

Discover more in Melbourne

Explore another side of the city's food and drink.

Browse all Melbourne venues